A starter:
Neil Sheehan, whose study of a Vietnam policy-maker, A Bright and Shining Lie, won considerable acclaim, attempts to duplicate his success with a biography of Cold War missile engineer Bernard Schriever. Reviewer J. Peter Scoblic says it does not succeed, challenging the book's entire logic regarding the strategic and historical role of the ICBM. ("Did Missiles Win the Cold War? A Soulless New Book Gets the History Wrong," The New Republic, 2 Dec. 2009. Among other things, the review picks out "one of the book's more infelicitous sentences":
technology was in the saddle of a horse named Fear in a race of human folly
Ouch! None of my students this semester displayed such a misguided striving for effect (though there were other mistakes aplenty).
It's a target-rich environment out there.
Suggestions welcome here, too.
No comments:
Post a Comment